A mobile-phone video recorded by a federal immigration agent has brought new scrutiny to the fatal shooting of Renee Nicole Good earlier this week in Minneapolis. The footage, confirmed as authentic by the Department of Homeland Security, captures the tense moments leading up to and immediately following the incident.
The 47-second clip, obtained by the conservative media outlet Alpha News, shows Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent Jonathan Ross approaching a burgundy SUV that was blocking traffic on Wednesday afternoon. The driver, 37-year-old Renee Good, is seen with her window down as Ross silently approaches with his phone raised.
The video, which contains graphic content, begins with Good addressing Ross, saying, “That’s fine dude. I’m not mad at you.” As the agent continues to circle the vehicle, another woman, believed to be Good’s wife, Rebecca, confronts him with her own phone, challenging the agent about their vehicle’s number plate.
Details of the Incident
As tensions escalate, another officer is heard shouting at Good to exit the vehicle. In response, Good reverses momentarily, then drives forward, prompting Ross to shout “whoa” before firing shots in quick succession. The video concludes with the sound of the SUV crashing into a parked car, accompanied by a male voice uttering an expletive.
The video has intensified the debate over the shooting, which Minnesota officials have labeled unjustified. However, ICE and the Trump administration have defended the agent’s actions, citing a need for self-defense.
Polarized Reactions
The incident has highlighted deep divisions within the United States regarding immigration enforcement under President Donald Trump. Both supporters and critics of the administration have used the same footage to bolster their arguments, reflecting a nation sharply divided on the issue.
Vice President JD Vance criticized media coverage of the event, describing it as “shameless press propaganda.” He noted that Ross, the officer involved, had previously been injured in a separate vehicle attack six months prior. Meanwhile, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem stated in a New York press conference that the agent “followed his training” and acted in self-defense, although the shooting remains under investigation.
Community Response and Protests
Renee Good’s death has sparked protests in Minneapolis and beyond, with civil-rights groups calling for an independent investigation. Minnesota officials have expressed frustration, claiming federal authorities initially agreed to a collaborative investigation before excluding state investigators.
Rebecca Good, in a statement to Minnesota Public Radio, described her late wife as a kind-hearted mother of three. “We had whistles. They had guns,” she wrote, expressing her commitment to raising their son with the values Renee cherished. Rebecca also thanked supporters nationwide for their solidarity.
Looking Ahead
The shooting has reignited discussions about the methods and ethics of immigration enforcement in America. As the investigation continues, the incident may influence future policy decisions and public opinion on immigration practices.
The Department of Homeland Security confirmed that Agent Ross was treated for injuries at a local hospital and subsequently released. As the nation grapples with the implications of this tragic event, the call for transparency and accountability in law enforcement remains a pressing issue.
