As dawn breaks over Melbourne, a trio of true crime enthusiasts, self-dubbed the “three mushkateers,” eagerly await the verdict in Erin Patterson’s trial at the Supreme Court. Among them is a woman who, at 16, discovered her passion for true crime through Vikki Petraitis’ book, The Frankston Serial Killer. This passion has led her to amass a library of 600 to 700 true-crime books.
Arriving early to secure a seat in the courtroom, the group has become a fixture at the trial, which has captivated the public’s attention. “Once I read that book, I haven’t read a fiction book since,” she shares, citing a particular interest in the infamous Easey Street murders of 1977. “I will be in the front row for that,” she adds, her fascination with the legal proceedings evident.
The Allure of True Crime
Erin Patterson’s trial marks the first murder trial attended by the Melburnian, whose interest in true crime has provided her with a unique perspective. “I loved watching the legal brains,” she remarks, noting the dynamic exchanges between defense lawyers Colin Mandy and Bill Doogue. Despite her familiarity with crime stories, the reality of the courtroom has been a revelation.
Her interest in psychology, sparked by a childhood encounter with crime, has fueled her desire to understand the criminal mind. “I really want to know how that brain works,” she reflects, recalling how different the ’80s were when such experiences were often brushed aside.
Community and Connection
Throughout the trial, the “three mushkateers” have formed a bond with fellow attendees, braving early mornings and cold temperatures to secure their spots. Among them is Kelly Phelan, a local from Traralgon, who was drawn to the case after hearing about it on the radio. Despite initial nerves, she found camaraderie with Egglestone and another woman, Angela Ely.
Phelan, a mother of six and dairy farm owner, has found the trial to be a source of fascination and discussion at home. Her youngest child has developed an interest in crime, often engaging in conversations about the case during family meals. “I came alone the first day. It was scary, I was so nervous,” she recalls, noting how the shared experience has led to new friendships.
The Reality of Courtroom Drama
Expectations of a trial akin to television dramas like Law and Order were quickly dispelled for Phelan. “It’s nothing like I expected,” she admits, as the trial extended beyond its anticipated duration, impacting her daily life. Her husband, Brett, has been supportive, taking on additional farm duties to allow her to attend the trial.
“I get up at 4.30am to feed calves, run back up to the house, do school lunches, duck into the shower and yell out, ‘come on, guys’ before the school run,” she describes, illustrating the juggling act required to balance her responsibilities.
Looking Ahead
As the trial draws to a close, the “three mushkateers” reflect on their journey, which has been as much about the friendships forged as the legal proceedings themselves. The verdict, eagerly anticipated, will mark the end of a chapter for these true crime aficionados, who have found humor and humanity amidst the gravity of the courtroom.
Their experience underscores the enduring allure of true crime, a genre that continues to captivate and connect individuals from all walks of life. As they prepare to leave Morwell, they carry with them not only the memories of the trial but also the bonds formed in the shared pursuit of justice and understanding.
