The speed of light has long been a cornerstone of physics, underpinning theories that have shaped our understanding of the universe. For over a century, the notion that light travels through space at a constant speed has been a fundamental principle. However, a recent study is challenging this concept, suggesting new pathways for future research by synthesizing decades of observations with cutting-edge analytical techniques.
This development follows a comprehensive review of efforts to test the constancy of light’s speed, offering a refined framework for examining one of nature’s most basic laws. The study revisits the historical roots of this inquiry, dating back to 1887, when Albert Michelson and Edward Morley conducted experiments that eventually inspired Einstein’s theory of special relativity. This theory asserts that the speed of light in a vacuum is constant and forms the basis of quantum field theory and the Standard Model of particle physics.
The Legacy of Lorentz Invariance
The concept of Lorentz invariance, which posits that the laws of physics are the same for all observers, is central to both quantum theory and general relativity. However, these two pillars of modern physics are not entirely compatible, especially at extremely small scales. Quantum theory describes particles using probability waves, while general relativity treats gravity as a curvature of spacetime. The search for a theory of quantum gravity has led scientists to question whether Lorentz invariance might break down at high energies.
If Lorentz invariance is violated, even slightly, it could mean that photons emitted simultaneously from a distant cosmic event might not reach Earth at the same time. To investigate this possibility, scientists have been studying high-energy light from cosmic phenomena such as pulsars, active galaxies, and gamma-ray bursts.
High Energy Light as a Testbed
These cosmic events release light across a broad energy spectrum, sometimes from billions of light-years away. A minuscule change in photon speed could manifest as a measurable delay over such vast distances. Previous research has correlated a photon’s energy with its travel time to set limits on the energy scale associated with quantum gravity.
Recent advancements have pushed lower-order effects to energy limits near the Planck scale, while higher-order effects remain elusive. However, improved detectors and new bursts have refined these estimates. Theorists have also developed the Standard Model Extension, a framework that describes potential Lorentz violations with various coefficients, each representing a different type of deviation in photon behavior.
A New Framework for a Complex Problem
The latest study addresses the challenge of translating astrophysical measurements into the Standard Model Extension framework. By focusing on nonbirefringent coefficients, the researchers avoid complications related to polarization. They demonstrate how to express photon dispersion parameters using spherical harmonics, enabling the mapping of each cosmic burst to a weighted sum of these coefficients.
To ensure consistent limits, the team corrected past measurements, accounting for previously omitted terms and systematic uncertainties. They updated uncertainties for instruments like the Fermi Large Area Telescope and LHAASO and converted older one-sided limits into two-sided limits at a 95% confidence level. New sources, including the Crab Pulsar and recent gamma-ray bursts GRB 190114C and GRB 221009A, were included, with the latter providing the strongest constraint yet, improving previous limits by more than tenfold.
Turning Observations Into a Clear Picture
The study compiled 65 measurements to solve for 25 different coefficients, treating each as a probability distribution. By combining these into a multidimensional Gaussian, the researchers could extract individual limits for each coefficient, showing improvements of roughly an order of magnitude across the board.
The authors emphasize the importance of consistent reporting and access to full likelihood curves for future research. They note that a single burst cannot rule out delays caused within the source itself, underscoring the need for a broad set of observations to reach definitive conclusions. With additional strong measurements, sensitivity to certain coefficients could improve significantly.
This work connects two major avenues in the search for Lorentz invariance violations. By updating past measurements and providing a unified translation method, the researchers have created a roadmap for future comparisons. Their findings highlight the potential of light that has traversed the universe for billions of years to reveal fundamental truths about nature’s laws.
Institutions such as the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona and the University of Algarve are at the forefront of this research. According to researcher Mercè Guerrero and her team, their goal was to test Einstein’s theories with the most precise astrophysical data available. While their findings did not overturn relativity, they significantly sharpened existing limits.
Practical Implications of the Research
This study strengthens the foundation for testing quantum gravity theories by providing a consistent framework for comparing results from various observatories. Improved limits on Lorentz invariance violations guide theorists toward models that align with the observable universe. As technology advances, scientists may eventually determine whether light’s speed is truly constant or if deeper layers of physics remain hidden.
The research findings are published in the journal Physical Review D.
Related Stories:
- Scientists prepare to launch tiny lifeforms into space at near the speed of light
- Cutting-edge rocket engine could accelerate to 99% the speed of light
- Can you time travel by going faster than the speed of light?
Like these kinds of feel-good stories? Get The Brighter Side of News’ newsletter.
