The Oscar buzz surrounding Rose Byrne’s new film If I Had Legs I’d Kick You is intensifying, with the anxiety-inducing, genre-bending flick described as a “dark comedic psychological drama.” This film, which centers on a mother grappling with her child’s chronic condition and refusal to eat, offers a raw portrayal of modern motherhood. Byrne’s performance as Linda, an existentially exhausted therapist and mother, is both brilliant and haunting.
The film’s tight, unrelenting shots mirror the relentless reality of the condition it depicts. As Linda navigates the demands of her daughter and the dismissive criticism of her absent husband, the audience is drawn into the suffocating tension of her world. This film is part of a broader trend that places the unvarnished realities of motherhood under a microscope.
The Rise of Motherhood as a Psychological Thriller
This development follows a series of works that explore the darker aspects of motherhood. The film adaptation of Rachel Yoder’s critically acclaimed novel Nightbitch, released in December 2024, tells the story of an overwhelmed former artist who becomes convinced she is transforming into a dog. Similarly, Jessamine Chan’s The School For Good Mothers presents a dystopian future where mothers are judged and re-educated by a government facility.
Meanwhile, Ashley Audrain’s The Push delves into generational trauma and maternal bonding challenges in a psychological suspense narrative. These stories reflect an increasing interest in the existential dread that can accompany motherhood, a theme that resonates with many.
A Historical Perspective on Motherhood Narratives
Of course, this is not the first time the complexities of motherhood have entered popular discourse. The early 2000s saw the rise of “mummy-blogging,” which popularized the “hot mess” mom trope. At the time, it felt revolutionary to openly discuss the overwhelm and identity loss associated with motherhood.
However, the pendulum soon swung in the opposite direction, with the emergence of creators like Nara Smith and Ariele Charnas, whose aspirational content suggested that children only enhance a mother’s life. Now, as societal challenges grow, so does the portrayal of the discomfort of modern motherhood.
The Nuances of Modern Motherhood
According to experts, capturing the full spectrum of motherhood’s challenges and joys is crucial. While films like If I Had Legs I’d Kick You highlight the psychological toll, they also underscore the moments of profound love that coexist with the drudgery of obligation.
“Yes, the slow seepage of self from a woman’s body during early motherhood is the stuff of psychological thrillers, but there’s also beautiful, absurd transcendence,” says Dr. Emily Carter, a psychologist specializing in maternal mental health.
In Byrne’s film, the juxtaposition of high-stakes panic with mundane repetition creates a tension that only an actress of her caliber can convey. This portrayal resonates deeply with mothers, offering a sense of recognition and connection.
Looking Ahead: The Impact of Motherhood Thrillers
The move represents a shift in how motherhood is depicted in media, providing a more nuanced view that acknowledges both the challenges and the joys. As these narratives continue to evolve, they offer a powerful means for mothers to see themselves reflected on screen and to find solace in shared experiences.
As we look to the future, the hope is that these stories will continue to foster understanding and empathy, allowing mothers to connect with one another in meaningful ways. By embracing the complexities of motherhood, we can better support each other through the journey.
