September 15, 2025 — 12:04am
As a self-proclaimed cruise snob, I had long dismissed the towering cruise ships anchored at Sydney’s Circular Quay as symbols of gaudy tourism. The sight of passengers in matching Hawaiian shirts towing oversized suitcases seemed to encapsulate the stereotype that cruising in Australia was loud and unsophisticated. However, after spending four days aboard the Carnival Adventure, I find myself pleasantly humbled. It turns out, I had been missing out on a world of fun.
According to a report by Cruise Lines International, Australians rank as the fourth-largest cruise market globally, a remarkable feat given the nation’s population size. In 2024, nearly one in every 20 Australians embarked on an ocean cruise. Notably, two trends have emerged: the average age of passengers is dropping, and shorter cruises, lasting three to four days, are gaining popularity.
The Transformation of a Cruise Icon
I embarked on a four-night taster cruise, marking not only my first voyage but also the inaugural season of the P&O workhorse, Adventure, under its new identity with Carnival Cruise Line. The transition has not been without its controversies. Loyalists of the P&O Australia brand expressed discontent when Carnival absorbed Adventure and Splendour into its fleet.
Some changes have been well-received: passengers now enjoy the perk of bringing a 750-millilitre bottle of wine onboard, and beloved features like Luke Mangan’s restaurant remain. Carnival’s onboard app has also been praised for its user-friendliness. However, not all aspects have translated seamlessly. For instance, the trivia host’s attempt to engage Australians with questions about American culture, like Lucky Charms cereal and the Declaration of Independence, fell flat.
Onboard Experience: A Mix of Tradition and Novelty
While waiting for coffee on deck five, I encountered a couple of seasoned cruisers. When I inquired if it was their first cruise, they laughed, revealing their platinum membership badges. “We’ve got six more cruises booked this year,” they shared, underscoring their loyalty to the Carnival brand despite the rebranding.
Determined to embrace the full experience, I participated in every activity available. From dining at every restaurant to attending shows and engaging in activities like Build-a-Bear workshops and burlesque shows, I tried it all. Despite the packed schedule, I couldn’t cover everything. Yet, I found joy in singing along to “Sweet Caroline” at the piano bar, attending comedy shows, and dancing at an ’80s rock’n’glow party. Even when rough seas prevented us from disembarking at Moreton Island, the ship offered enough entertainment to keep spirits high.
Accommodations and Dining: Comfort Meets Culinary Delight
My balcony stateroom exceeded expectations with its spacious walk-in robe, compact bathroom, and an outdoor balcony offering stunning views of the Harbour Bridge and the east coast. The thrill of navigating through big swells added an exhilarating touch to the journey, reminding me of the untamed nature of the sea.
Dining onboard was a concern due to my dietary restrictions, but the staff’s attentiveness quickly put me at ease. Each meal began with a confirmation of my allergy, ensuring a safe dining experience. The general pantry buffet on level 14 became my go-to for lunch, serving delightful Mexican cuisine. At night, Luke Mangan’s Luke’s Bar & Grill stood out as a culinary highlight.
The Appeal of Short Cruises
During a visit to the bridge, the chief engineer shared insights into the ship’s navigation and stabilisation systems. “She’s not a young lady, but she’s doing well,” he remarked, reflecting the ship’s enduring charm. As I near the average cruise age of 48.4, cruising seems inevitable. However, like me, 70% of those aboard the Carnival Adventure were first-time cruisers.
In the disco, I met a group of first-time cruisers in their late 20s. They had chosen a short cruise from a capital city as an introduction to cruising. Before I could ask if they’d cruise again, the DJ played “Dancing Queen,” prompting us to rush to the dance floor.
Conclusion: Fun, Affordable, and Inclusive
While some ships focus on exotic destinations or luxury, Carnival Adventure is all about fun. The atmosphere of inclusivity, coupled with an affordable price point, makes it appealing to a broad audience. Despite the numerous add-ons that can increase costs, the overall experience is easy and enjoyable.
Would I cruise again? Surprisingly, yes. I’m already planning a trip with friends, complete with matching T-shirts. Would I recommend it? Absolutely. I know my parents would love the piano-bar singalongs, and I’m helping them choose a cruise for later in the year. However, it’s not for everyone. But sometimes, a holiday just needs to be simple and fun.
Shaney Hudson is an award-winning freelance travel writer based in Sydney, specializing in family travel. She enjoys exploring where the wild things are.
