February 17, 2026 — The Cook government was taken by surprise following a decision by the City of Perth and the Public Transport Authority (PTA) to install speakers emitting a high-pitched noise under a bridge in East Perth. This measure aimed to deter homeless individuals from setting up tents at a well-known encampment site along a cycle path.
The PTA confirmed that speakers were installed at the City of Perth’s request, playing the noise continuously under the Lord Street overpass, located 150 meters northeast of McIver train station. While the City of Perth defended its decision, it clarified that operational control rested with the PTA.
Government Response and Public Backlash
Premier Roger Cook expressed disapproval, stating that the decision was made at a lower agency level and did not align with his government’s policy. “Obviously, this is not what we do in Western Australia. We try to avoid persecuting or making life uncomfortable for people who are homeless and already experiencing a great deal of discomfort,” Cook remarked.
This area has historically been a gathering place for rough sleepers, leading to the erection of large fences and tents being pitched along the cycle path. After advocates for the homeless raised concerns, the PTA discontinued the noise on Tuesday morning.
Historical Context of Hostile Architecture
The use of sound and architecture to deter anti-social behavior is not new and has been contentious. In 2023, the City of Bunbury faced criticism for playing The Wiggles’ “Hot Potato” on loop at a popular homeless gathering spot, prompting an apology.
A City of Perth spokeswoman explained that the devices were installed in response to reports of anti-social and criminal behavior. “The device forms one part of a broader safety approach and was implemented in response to requests for action to help improve the safe use of the space. It is not intended to target or deter people experiencing homelessness,” she stated.
Political and Community Reactions
Housing Minister and Perth MP John Carey, a former homelessness minister, was caught off guard by the noise installation. He emphasized that such hostile measures were not supported by his government, although he acknowledged the area’s challenges.
“I wasn’t aware of it, so it has caught me by surprise. But what hasn’t caught me by surprise has been the challenges at that particular pocket. It is well known by the local community,” Carey said.
He added that the PTA had turned off the noise and would collaborate with the City of Perth to find a more suitable solution. Carey highlighted the need for improved lighting and enhanced homeless outreach as better deterrents for anti-social behavior.
Advocacy and Future Steps
Homelessness advocate Jesse Noakes questioned the ethics of the noise deterrent, asking how officials would feel if such noise played outside their homes all night. This sentiment underscores the ongoing debate about humane and effective solutions to homelessness and public safety.
The PTA confirmed that the noise device had been deactivated and emphasized its commitment to working with the City of Perth to develop a more appropriate strategy.
As the city grapples with balancing public safety and the rights of its homeless population, this incident highlights the complexities and sensitivities involved in urban management and social policy. The government and local authorities are now tasked with finding a path forward that respects both community safety and the dignity of those experiencing homelessness.
