The judges didn’t have a lot of love for The Brady Bunch star despite his recent birthday.
Published on October 3, 2023
On the second week of Dancing With the Stars, the s— hit the ballroom floor.
Following their Cha-Cha to “Oye Como Va” by Tito Puente, Peta Murgatroyd and Brady Bunch star Barry Williams were met with less than stellar scores from the judges. When Murgatroyd saw the low score (a 5) from Carrie Ann Inaba, she responded by saying something like, “Oh s—” or “Bulls—-.”
The curse word didn’t make it to air, but you could see her mouthing the words and the broadcast was silent for a few seconds as Murgatroyd was bleeped.
Murgatroyd’s frustration may have stemmed not only from her belief in her and Williams’ performance, but the fact that Latin night also came on the heels of the actor’s 69th birthday. The pre-dance package showcased Williams, Murgatroyd, and other competing couples celebrating Williams’ birthday in the rehearsal room. Williams then said that the best birthday gift would be receiving high scores from the judges.
But his birthday wish was not to be — the couple received a total of 15 points out of 30 from the judges, one less than their score of 16 last week on the premiere. Williams danced a foxtrot to “It’s a Sunshine Day” by the Brady Bunch to kick off his time on the show.
Many of Williams’ fans online also took issue with the judges’ low scores. “He was WAY better than stiff Adrian, stiff Mira and stiff Tyson!! Why are the judges being so critical on him and not the others?!” one social media user said.
“Barry getting the same scores and lower than Adrian and Tyson? ageism. HOLD THE DWTS JUDGES ACCOUNTABLE #dwts,” wrote another.
Williams has been trying to get on DWTS for 17 years and describes his participation as one of the items on his bucket list.
Perhaps week 3 will bring a belated birthday present.
Dancing With the Stars airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+.
Sign up for Entertainment Weekly‘s free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.