Welcome back to The 25, where AFL.com.au’s team of experts ranks the best players in the game. As the 2025 AFL season reaches its climax, the completion of the home and away matches has allowed our panel of journalists and experts to compile the list of the top 25 players for September. This month, the rankings see significant movement with just one new entrant compared to August’s list.
Every month throughout 2025, AFL.com.au has been ranking the best 25 players in the AFL competition, considering both recent form and a body of work across previous seasons. With the grand finale of the season fast approaching, these rankings provide a snapshot of the players who have defined the year.
New Entrants and Rising Stars
Among the notable new entrants is Finn Callaghan, whose stellar performance this year has earned him a spot in the 44-man All-Australian squad. Callaghan has taken his game to another level, becoming a pivotal figure in the Giants’ midfield with career-high averages for disposals, clearances, and tackles.
Sam Taylor, despite missing several games, has also made his mark, leading the league for intercept marks. His defensive prowess is crucial for the Giants’ aspirations in September.
Consistent Performers and Key Contributors
Meanwhile, players like Chad Warner and Ed Richards have continued to impress. Warner, despite the Swans’ underwhelming season, remains a formidable player with his ability to win clearances and kick goals. Richards, on the other hand, has enjoyed a breakthrough season, leading the league for goal assists and earning his first All-Australian blazer.
Another standout is Toby Greene, whose late-game heroics have once again highlighted his importance to the Giants. Greene’s ability to perform on the biggest stage makes him a player to watch as the finals approach.
Veterans and Their Impact
Veteran players like Lachie Neale and Max Gawn continue to demonstrate their elite status. Neale, despite a season interrupted by injury, remains a key figure for Brisbane, while Gawn’s leadership and performance have solidified his place among the greats, earning him his eighth All-Australian selection.
Jeremy Cameron, the brilliant Cats spearhead, claimed his second Coleman Medal and was named an All-Australian for the fifth time. His goal-scoring prowess makes him a significant threat in the finals.
Looking Ahead to the Finals
As the AFL finals loom, the players on this list will be pivotal in their teams’ quests for glory. With the final rankings of the year set to be released after the Grand Final, fans and experts alike will be watching closely to see who rises to the occasion.
The rankings not only highlight individual brilliance but also underscore the dynamic nature of the AFL, where new talents emerge, and veterans continue to leave their mark. The anticipation builds as the league’s best prepare to showcase their skills on the grandest stage.
Stay tuned for the final edition of The 25 after the Grand Final, where the ultimate rankings of 2025 will be revealed.
