The trade and free agency period is often seen as the perfect opportunity for AFL clubs to address pressing list needs. However, even the most successful teams enter the off-season with lingering questions. As the 2026 AFL season approaches, every club faces unique challenges that could define their upcoming campaign.
While some gaps might be filled through drafts, delisted free agency, or the SSP (Pre-Season Supplemental Selection Period), significant concerns remain. Below, we analyze each club’s key list chasm for the 2026 AFL season.
Adelaide Crows: Midfield Versatility and Potency
Adelaide’s pursuit of Christian Petracca during the trade period underscored their need for a more dynamic midfield. The Crows struggled to compete with top contenders, particularly when the pressure intensified in September. The absence of Izak Rankine was felt, as his presence could have provided the X-factor needed alongside Josh Rachele. Young talents like Sid Draper and Dan Curtin might offer the boost required to elevate the midfield. Meanwhile, players such as Jake Soligo and Sam Berry gaining finals experience could prove invaluable.
Brisbane Lions: Replacing Brandon Starcevich
Brandon Starcevich’s departure leaves a noticeable void in Brisbane’s defense. Known for his ability to shut down key opponents like Patrick Dangerfield and Tom Papley, his absence is significant. With Noah Answerth sidelined due to injury, the Lions must identify a suitable replacement. Keidean Coleman’s return offers some hope, but his offensive style differs from Starcevich’s defensive prowess. The Lions’ otherwise strong lineup, bolstered by Oscar Allen and Sam Draper, will need to adapt.
Carlton: Run, Carry, and Polish
Carlton’s challenge lies in transitioning from a contest-heavy style to a more dynamic, high-speed game. The Blues made several strategic acquisitions, including Will Hayward and Oliver Florent, to inject pace and skill. However, questions remain about the team’s ball usage quality. The return of Nic Newman and the potential growth of players like Jesse Motlop could be pivotal. Carlton’s ability to adapt its game plan will be crucial in determining its success.
Collingwood: A Consistent Second Midfield Star
Collingwood’s need for a reliable key forward is evident, especially after Brody Mihocek’s departure. However, the team’s midfield requires reinforcement to support Nick Daicos. The preliminary final loss to Brisbane highlighted the need for more midfield depth. Ned Long’s emergence is promising, but Craig McRae must find another game-breaker to complement Daicos. Josh Daicos and Beau McCreery are potential candidates, while a healthier Jordan De Goey could make a significant difference.
Essendon: Health and Depth Concerns
Essendon’s 2025 season was marred by injuries, leaving the team’s true potential largely untested. The Bombers face challenges in the ruck position, with Nick Bryan injured and limited options available. The midfield, led by Zach Merrett, also lacks depth. Essendon’s forward line struggled for consistency, with no player scoring over 30 goals in 2025. Addressing these issues will be vital for the Bombers’ resurgence.
Fremantle: Strengthening Key Defensive Stocks
Fremantle’s list appears well-rounded, but there is room to bolster key defensive stocks. The Dockers’ small forwards underperformed in the elimination final, yet the team remains strong in that area. The addition of Judd McVee enhances their defensive versatility. A healthy season from Hayden Young and the continued development of stars like Caleb Serong and Andrew Brayshaw will be crucial for Fremantle’s success.
Geelong: Ruck and Midfield Depth
Geelong’s midfield depth was exposed during the grand final. While Bailey Smith and Max Holmes are standout performers, the supporting cast lacks consistency. The ruck situation remains unresolved, with Rhys Stanley expected to lead once again. The Cats have managed without a star ruckman for years, but new rules could impact the role’s importance.
Gold Coast Suns: Star Small Forward
Gold Coast boasts a promising group of key forwards, but the absence of a star small forward is notable. Ben Long’s impressive season offers hope, but consistency is key. The Suns could benefit from more creative forwards, despite their aerial strength. Closing the gap on premiership contention remains a priority.
GWS Giants: Midfield Questions
The Giants have strengthened their midfield with Clayton Oliver, but questions remain about his fit alongside Tom Green. GWS may need to upgrade their ruck department, with limited options available. Addressing these concerns will be essential for the Giants’ competitiveness.
Hawthorn: Game-Breaking Midfielder
Hawthorn’s midfield lacks the star power needed to compete with the best. The absence of Zach Merrett was felt, and the team will rely on players like Cam Mackenzie to step up. A fit Will Day and Jai Newcombe could significantly boost the Hawks’ prospects.
Melbourne: Spine Concerns
Melbourne’s acquisition of Brody Mihocek addresses a key-position attack need, but concerns about the spine persist. The Demons are prioritizing the development of younger defenders, which may lead to growing pains. Improving their defensive output is crucial for success.
North Melbourne: Reliability at Both Ends
North Melbourne’s depth in the engine room is commendable, but reliability at both ends of the ground is lacking. The team must develop a consistent back six and address forward line concerns. Investing in a key forward through the draft could be a strategic move.
Port Adelaide: Half-Back Punish
Port Adelaide’s half-back line struggled to fill the void left by Dan Houston. The team needs to enhance its counterpunch ability from the backline. Addressing this gap will be vital for success in the modern game.
Richmond: Two-Way Midfielder
Richmond’s midfield combinations require improvement, particularly in terms of pace and defensive transition. The team ranked poorly in clearance and contested possession differentials. The emergence of young talents like Sam Lalor offers hope for the future.
St Kilda: Key-Position Attack
St Kilda’s tall attack has been hampered by Max King’s injury woes. The team must find a reliable forward partner for King. The dynamic between Tom De Koning and Rowan Marshall will be closely watched.
Sydney Swans: Key Back Stocks
Sydney’s acquisition of Jai Serong addresses some defensive concerns, but key back depth remains an issue. The team must develop young defenders to ensure long-term stability. Improving defensive metrics is essential for the Swans’ success.
West Coast Eagles: Midfield Support
West Coast’s midfield struggles were evident, with Harley Reid unable to shoulder the load alone. The addition of Deven Robertson could provide much-needed support. Drafting a top prospect like Willem Duursma would further bolster the midfield.
Western Bulldogs: Key Defensive Stopper
The Western Bulldogs must address their need for a key defensive stopper. Strengthening their backline will be crucial for the team’s competitiveness in the upcoming season.
As the 2026 AFL season approaches, clubs will continue to assess and address their list challenges. The ability to adapt and strengthen key areas will be pivotal in determining success on the field.
