EAST LANSING, Mich. – In an era dominated by digital innovation, a new study from Michigan State University (MSU) underscores the enduring power of traditional print activities in fostering early literacy among preschoolers. The research, which has been published in the Journal of Research in Reading, reveals that simple, hands-on activities such as writing letters and identifying words in daily life significantly enhance early reading skills.
Conducted by professors Lori Skibbe and Ryan Bowles, alongside former postdoctoral researcher Nick Waters, the study highlights that children engaged in print-related activities demonstrated greater literacy gains compared to those who spent more time on digital or analog literacy games. The findings suggest that while digital tools are prevalent, they may not be as beneficial as once thought, particularly for children with typical learning development.
Understanding the Study’s Methodology
The MSU research team focused on the home literacy environment, a critical period for developing literacy skills outside the classroom. They categorized activities into three types: print-focused activities, shared book reading, and literacy games. The study involved over 1,000 children aged 3 to 6 from diverse families across a Midwestern state, with a significant portion having speech and/or language impairments.
Parents provided data through surveys detailing their engagement in various literacy activities at home. Researchers assessed children’s literacy development through foundational skills such as letter-name knowledge, letter-sound knowledge, and phonological awareness.
Key Findings and Implications
The study’s findings are clear: print-focused activities consistently predicted stronger early literacy skills across all children. Conversely, increased time spent on literacy games correlated with lower reading assessment scores, regardless of a child’s developmental background.
“Print-focused activities consistently predicted stronger early literacy skills in all children studied.”
Interestingly, shared book reading was only a significant predictor of literacy development for children without speech and/or language impairments. This suggests that while the home literacy environment’s structure is similar for all children, special attention is needed for shared reading with those who have disabilities.
The Role of Digital Tools in Early Literacy
This research challenges the assumption that more exposure to learning games automatically enhances literacy. Instead, it emphasizes the need for intentional, hands-on approaches to literacy development. Digital learning tools, while not to be avoided entirely, should serve as supplemental rather than primary educational resources.
What Parents Should Know About Educational Games
There are several reasons why some educational games may not be effective. For instance, many prioritize entertainment over education, using flashy visuals and sounds that can distract from skill development. Moreover, even high-quality games often lack the personal, hands-on instruction crucial for developing early reading skills, particularly for children with speech and/or language challenges.
“Teaching children early reading skills does not require expensive tools or programs. Everyday interactions with print learning opportunities are the most important.”
Parents can encourage literacy by integrating simple activities into daily routines. Suggestions include:
- Spotting letters on street signs, food packaging, or menus.
- Encouraging writing by having children write their names, draw letters, or label pictures.
- Making reading interactive by pointing to words, discussing letter sounds, and asking questions during storytime.
Looking Forward: The Future of Early Literacy Education
The MSU study provides valuable insights for parents, educators, and developers, prompting a reevaluation of strategies to support early literacy. As digital tools continue to evolve, the challenge will be to balance their use with traditional methods that have proven effective over time.
Ultimately, the research suggests that while technology has its place, the foundational skills of reading are best nurtured through direct, hands-on engagement with print. This approach is especially crucial for children with learning impairments, who benefit most from print-focused routines.
By Madeline Strauss
Read more on MSUToday.
