In a thrilling opportunity for fans of the beloved series Our Flag Means Death, Heritage Auctions has announced an online auction featuring props and costumes from the show. This comes a year and a half after HBO Max, then known simply as Max, cancelled the queer pirate comedy created by David Jenkins. The series, which starred Rhys Darby and Taika Waititi, may have ended, but its legacy lives on through this unique auction.
The auction is part of Heritage’s HBO Mashup event, which also includes items from other popular shows such as Barry, Big Little Lies, Curb Your Enthusiasm, White House Plumbers, and Perry Mason. Among the Our Flag Means Death lots are “Wanted” posters for Blackbeard, portrayed by Waititi, as well as pirate swords, daggers, and pistols. Fans can also bid on the mermaid tail worn by Stede Bonnet, played by Darby, during a significant dream sequence in Season 2. Additionally, several costume pieces, including Stede’s extravagant coats and Blackbeard’s leather battle attire, are up for grabs.
Excitement Among Fans
The announcement has generated considerable excitement among the show’s fanbase. At the time of writing, several lots are still available at a starting bid of $1. However, the most sought-after item, the Stede and Blackbeard wedding toppers from Season 2, has already surpassed $1,000. The auction is set to conclude on August 23, giving fans a limited window to secure a piece of the series.
The auction not only offers fans a chance to own a piece of television history but also reflects the enduring appeal of Our Flag Means Death. Despite its cancellation, the series has maintained a devoted following, with fans eager to celebrate its unique blend of comedy and representation.
Previous Auctions and Fan Initiatives
This is not the first time items from Our Flag Means Death have been auctioned. In February and March of 2025, fans organized the Our Flag Means Death craft fair, a 19-day fundraiser that successfully raised $105,000 for the Campaign for Southern Equality’s Trans Youth Emergency Project. The event featured fan-created items, from embroidery to jewelry, alongside donations from the show’s cast and crew. Notably, creator David Jenkins contributed an Our Flag Means Death teapot and a prop doodled on by Waititi during filming.
Impact and Cultural Significance
The enduring popularity of Our Flag Means Death can be attributed to its groundbreaking representation of queer relationships and its humorous yet poignant storytelling. The series has been praised for its inclusive narrative, which resonated with audiences seeking diverse and authentic representation on screen.
According to television critic Jamie Thompson, “The show’s ability to weave humor with heartfelt moments set it apart in a crowded television landscape. Its cancellation was a disappointment to many, but events like this auction keep the spirit of the show alive.”
“The show’s ability to weave humor with heartfelt moments set it apart in a crowded television landscape.” – Jamie Thompson, Television Critic
Looking Ahead
As the auction draws to a close, fans of Our Flag Means Death have a unique opportunity to own a tangible piece of the series. The event also serves as a reminder of the show’s cultural impact and the community it fostered. While the series may no longer be in production, its legacy continues to inspire and connect fans across the globe.
For those interested in participating, the auction remains open until August 23, providing a final chance to bid on these cherished items. As fans eagerly await the outcome, the auction stands as a testament to the enduring love for Our Flag Means Death and its place in television history.
