The latest round of the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season delivered a rollercoaster of emotions, with teams experiencing both triumphs and disasters. The weekend saw five teams achieve perfect grades, while five others fell short, marking one of the most extreme rounds in recent memory.
Every team’s performance was meticulously analyzed and graded in foxfooty.com.au’s Round 20 edition of the Report Card. The highs and lows of the round provide a fascinating snapshot of the current state of the league.
Adelaide Crows: A Dominant Display
The Adelaide Crows made a significant statement with a 98-point victory over Port Adelaide in the Showdown, marking the largest win in the rivalry’s history. The Crows’ explosive eight-goal fourth quarter showcased their prowess, prompting former Tigers champion Jack Riewoldt to describe Matthew Nicks’ team as the “complete package.”
Riley Thilthorpe was a standout, earning his second Showdown Medal with three goals from 19 disposals. Jake Soligo and James Peatling also delivered impressive performances, contributing to the Crows’ comprehensive win.
Grade: A+
Brisbane Lions: A Shock Defeat
The Brisbane Lions faced a surprising defeat in the QClash against the Gold Coast Suns. Despite a strong start, the Lions were overwhelmed as the Suns stormed home, setting new records in the process. Brisbane’s defense struggled under the pressure, conceding a record 13.6 (84) from stoppage clearances alone.
Lachie Neale was a bright spot for the Lions, with 36 disposals, five tackles, and a goal. However, the team’s inability to adapt to the Suns’ onslaught was evident.
Grade: F
Collingwood: Back on Top
Collingwood returned to the top of the ladder with a 36-point victory over Richmond. Nick Daicos was instrumental, delivering a masterclass performance with 42 disposals, three goals, and 910 metres gained. The win sets up a crucial clash against Brisbane, with the Magpies looking to solidify their top-four position.
Despite the wet conditions, Collingwood managed to find their rhythm, with Isaac Quaynor and Tom Mitchell also making significant contributions.
Grade: B+
Geelong: Cameron’s Career Night
Jeremy Cameron stole the show at Marvel Stadium, kicking a career-best 11 goals to lead Geelong to a 101-point win over North Melbourne. This victory not only boosted the Cats’ percentage but also extended their winning streak over North to 14 games.
Cameron’s performance was complemented by Bailey Smith’s 43 disposals, as Geelong consolidated their top-four spot.
Grade: A+
Gold Coast Suns: Historic QClash Win
The Gold Coast Suns turned the tables on their rivals, the Brisbane Lions, with a record-breaking performance in the QClash. The Suns were relentless, achieving their highest score against the Lions and securing their biggest win in the rivalry.
Matt Rowell was awarded the Ashcroft Medal for his outstanding game, while Noah Anderson and Ben Long also shone, contributing to the Suns’ push for their first finals appearance.
Grade: A+
Melbourne: A Collapse for the Ages
Melbourne’s dramatic collapse against St Kilda will be remembered as one of the most brutal in AFL history. Leading by 46 points at three-quarter time, the Demons conceded the last nine goals of the match, resulting in a shocking loss.
Bayley Fritsch and Jack Viney were among the few positives for Melbourne, but the team’s inability to manage the game in the final quarter was glaring.
Grade: F
St Kilda: Miracle Comeback
St Kilda’s remarkable comeback against Melbourne was nothing short of miraculous. Overcoming a 46-point deficit, the Saints kicked 9.2 in the final quarter to secure a historic victory, with Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera sealing the win with a post-siren goal.
The Saints’ resilience and determination were on full display, with Wanganeen-Milera and Jack Higgins leading the charge.
Grade: A-
The weekend’s results have reshaped the AFL landscape, with teams now reassessing their strategies as the finals approach. The highs and lows of Round 20 will undoubtedly have lasting implications as the season progresses.
