Does Benji Marshall want to be a coach, or is he contemplating a return as a player? This is a question that Wests Tigers chief executive Shane Richardson might need to ask the 40-year-old Marshall following this week’s revelations. The former champion playmaker was reportedly involved in a training altercation with veteran back Adam Doueihi.
The incident reportedly occurred during the build-up to the round 16 game against Canberra. According to the Sydney Morning Herald, Doueihi took exception after Marshall tackled him during an opposed training session, leading to a verbal exchange in front of onlookers, likely other players and coaching staff.
This development comes as the Tigers are already grappling with internal issues. The story’s leak to the media suggests ulterior motives, possibly an attempt to undermine Marshall’s position. This leak coincides with the Tigers’ decision to allow young talent Tallyn Da Silva to leave for Parramatta, further fueling speculation about internal discord.
Internal Struggles and Leaks
The Tigers’ internal struggles are not new. Earlier this year, Lachlan Galvin’s departure amid bullying claims added to the club’s woes. Galvin left for Canterbury, despite having over a year left on his contract. The decision to let Da Silva go, purportedly to free up salary cap space, has been criticized as shortsighted, especially given the club’s current standing and future aspirations.
Richardson has previously emphasized the importance of nurturing homegrown talent rather than overpaying for external players. Yet, both Galvin and Da Silva, considered among the best young players in crucial positions, have left the club. This raises questions about the club’s strategy and internal management.
“It makes no sense to release either player at this point given they weren’t exactly on huge money by NRL standards,” a rival chief executive commented.
Benji Marshall’s Coaching Challenges
While Marshall is celebrated as one of the greatest players to wear the Tigers jersey, his transition to coaching has been fraught with challenges. With limited experience as an assistant under Tim Sheens, Marshall’s appointment as head coach was always a gamble. Now, less than two years into his tenure, the situation appears to be unraveling, with rumors of Willie Peters potentially replacing him if results do not improve.
Peters, currently successful with Hull KR in the Super League, has a history with Richardson from their time at South Sydney. Richardson has publicly backed Marshall to continue as coach next year, even if the Tigers finish last. However, a looming match against the Roosters could be pivotal. A heavy defeat would mark the Tigers’ seventh consecutive loss, intensifying pressure on Marshall.
Broader Implications for NRL Coaching
The turmoil at the Tigers reflects broader issues within the NRL regarding coaching appointments and stability. The league’s current stance on national team coaching roles further complicates the landscape. The recent debate over who should coach the Kangaroos highlights these challenges.
With Brad Fittler declining the Kangaroos coaching role, attention has turned to Cameron Smith and Kevvie Walters. However, the NRL’s rule barring current club coaches from national roles limits options. The league’s desire for the best players to represent Australia contrasts with its restrictions on coaching appointments.
“It should go to the best coach, if their club is willing to let them do it,” experts argue, pointing to the need for a re-evaluation of policies.
As the Tigers navigate their internal challenges, the broader NRL community watches closely, aware that the outcomes could influence future coaching decisions across the league. The coming weeks will be crucial for Marshall and the Tigers as they strive to stabilize and improve their standing.
