The 2025 AFL National Draft is fast approaching, with clubs diligently strategizing their first-round selections. Scheduled for November 19-20, the draft offers a blend of ready-made talents and long-term prospects, providing clubs with opportunities to address specific needs or bolster their rosters for future success.
Foxfooty.com.au has analyzed potential picks for each club, highlighting players who could be pivotal in addressing team weaknesses or enhancing existing strengths. Here’s a detailed look at who each club might consider with their first draft pick.
Adelaide Crows: Strengthening the Forward Line
The Adelaide Crows, reigning minor premiers, are eyeing Mitch Marsh from West Adelaide. While their list lacks glaring weaknesses, Marsh could enhance their forward options, especially if Izak Rankine transitions to a midfield role. Marsh, a 191-centimeter forward, led South Australia in goalkicking with a tournament-high 12 goals, drawing comparisons to Hawthorn’s Jack Gunston.
Marsh’s potential to replace veteran Taylor Walker, who may retire soon, adds to his appeal. The Crows’ pursuit of Cal Ah Chee underscores their need for long-term forward solutions, making Marsh a strategic choice.
Brisbane Lions: Building a Future Dynasty
Daniel Annable, a product of the Brisbane Lions Academy, is a standout candidate for the Lions. Known for his toughness and work ethic, Annable averaged 24.8 disposals and 4.2 clearances during the National Championships. His versatility allows him to play as a winger or half-forward, complementing Brisbane’s formidable midfield lineup.
“Annable is a consistent performer and a great leader among his peers, poised to join a midfield featuring Will Ashcroft and Lachie Neale,” noted a draft expert.
With Annable’s addition, Brisbane could be on the brink of another dynasty, reinforcing their midfield depth for the next decade.
Carlton: Securing Defensive Fortitude
Carlton is set to select Harry Dean, a promising defender from the Murray Bushrangers. Dean, a competitive key defender, is lauded for his intercept marking and left-footed kicking. His strong performance in the National Championships earned him All-Australian honors, making him a likely candidate for Carlton’s round one side.
As the son of former Blue Peter Dean, Harry brings a legacy of defensive prowess, poised to fortify Carlton’s backline.
Collingwood: Investing in Future Talent
Collingwood’s focus is on Zac McCarthy from the Oakleigh Chargers. As part of the Pies’ Next Generation Academy, McCarthy is a versatile tall who can play both forward and ruck roles. Although still developing, his potential to rejuvenate Collingwood’s aging forward line is significant.
With a bid expected in the first round, Collingwood is likely to match, ensuring McCarthy’s place in their long-term plans.
Essendon: Adding Midfield Dynamism
Sullivan Robey from the Eastern Ranges is on Essendon’s radar, especially if he slips past Richmond’s early picks. Robey’s rapid rise in the draft ranks is attributed to his dominant performances, including a 40-disposal game against the Western Jets. His comparison to Collingwood’s Jordan De Goey highlights his potential impact.
As a Bombers fan, Robey’s selection would not only excite supporters but also add a dynamic edge to Essendon’s developing list.
Fremantle: Planning for Defensive Succession
Fremantle is considering Blake Thredgold from Sturt to bolster their defensive stocks. With key defenders like Alex Pearce aging, Thredgold’s athleticism and pace make him a strategic choice for future planning. His comparison to Gold Coast’s Sam Collins underscores his potential as a reliable stopper.
With Fremantle’s current pick, Thredgold fits well within their draft strategy, aiming for sustained success.
Geelong: Embracing Long-Term Potential
Geelong’s strategy allows them to select high-upside players like Archie Ludowyke from the Sandringham Dragons. Despite injury setbacks, Ludowyke’s potential as a forward is immense, offering a future pairing with Shannon Neale post-Jeremy Cameron era.
Ludowyke’s game, modeled after Giants’ Aaron Cadman, positions him as a valuable long-term asset for the Cats.
Gold Coast Suns: Tapping into Academy Talent
Zeke Uwland, a Gold Coast Academy standout, is a top prospect despite a back injury limiting his 2025 season. Uwland’s foot skills and speed, likened to Sydney’s Errol Gulden, make him a coveted pick, likely attracting a top-five bid.
His leadership and football intelligence enhance his profile, making Uwland a potential cornerstone for the Suns.
GWS Giants: Seeking Defensive Versatility
Oskar Taylor from the Eastern Ranges is a promising option for the Giants, known for taking bold draft moves. Taylor’s speed and defensive consistency make him an ideal candidate to eventually succeed Lachie Whitfield.
“Taylor’s athletic prowess and defensive acumen align perfectly with the Giants’ dynamic style,” a draft analyst observed.
His potential to contribute to the Giants’ defensive strategy makes him a compelling choice.
Hawthorn: Strengthening the Rebound
Jacob Farrow from West Perth is a versatile defender/midfielder, drawing comparisons to Adelaide’s Jordan Dawson. Farrow’s kicking and ability to rebound effectively make him a valuable addition to Hawthorn’s lineup.
With a focus on transitioning from defense to midfield, Farrow could significantly boost Hawthorn’s future prospects.
Melbourne: Rebuilding the Midfield Core
Dyson Sharp from Central District is a prime candidate for Melbourne, following a significant off-season exodus. Sharp’s robust performance in the National Championships, earning him the Larke Medal, highlights his readiness for AFL competition.
His potential to lead Melbourne’s midfield renewal makes him a strategic pick for the Dees.
North Melbourne: Addressing Key Position Needs
Louis Emmett from the Oakleigh Chargers is a potential target for North Melbourne, focusing on key position players. Emmett’s mobility and contested marking ability make him an attractive long-term prospect.
With a need to support both ends of the ground, Emmett’s selection could address North’s strategic gaps.
Port Adelaide: Eyeing Defensive Reinforcements
Port Adelaide is considering Elliott Duffield from South Adelaide to strengthen their defensive lineup. Duffield’s decision-making and ball use make him a promising option, especially given Port’s current draft position.
With potential future picks in mind, Duffield’s selection could align with Port’s long-term planning.
Richmond: Bolstering Defensive Depth
Xavier Taylor from the Eastern Ranges is a strong candidate for Richmond, known for his versatility and defensive prowess. Compared to current Tigers stars, Taylor’s ability to play on both talls and smalls enhances his draft appeal.
His standout performance in the Coates Talent League grand final underscores his readiness for AFL competition.
St Kilda: Exploring Creative Draft Strategies
Kye Fincher from the Sandringham Dragons is a potential selection for St Kilda, part of their Next Generation Academy. Fincher’s speed and strength make him a versatile asset, although a creative approach may be needed to secure his selection.
With potential trades and surprises, St Kilda’s draft strategy remains dynamic and flexible.
Sydney Swans: Capitalizing on Academy Prospects
Max King, a Sydney Swans Academy product, is a top prospect despite not meeting external expectations. King’s physical prowess and VFL experience position him as a potential AFL impact player.
With multiple Academy prospects in play, Sydney’s draft strategy aims to maximize their talent pool.
West Coast Eagles: Securing Top Talent
Willem Duursma from Gippsland Power is a standout choice for West Coast, poised to be the number one pick. Duursma’s versatility and strong aerial capabilities make him an immediate impact player.
“Duursma’s mix of polish and hard work makes him a perfect fit for West Coast’s rebuilding efforts,” a draft expert commented.
His selection would mark a significant step in West Coast’s strategic rebuild.
Western Bulldogs: Enhancing Forward Options
Lachy Dovaston from the Eastern Ranges is a potential pick for the Bulldogs, focusing on small forward stocks. Dovaston’s dynamic play style and goal sense make him a fan favorite and immediate contributor.
With a need to bolster their forward line, Dovaston’s selection aligns with the Bulldogs’ strategic goals.
As the 2025 AFL Draft approaches, clubs are meticulously planning their selections, aiming to balance immediate needs with long-term potential. With a diverse pool of talent available, this year’s draft promises to shape the future of AFL teams significantly.
