Veteran AFL journalist Caroline Wilson has fiercely criticized Geelong Cats’ star midfielder Bailey Smith following a controversial Mad Monday celebration. The incident, which took place days after the Cats’ grand final defeat to Brisbane, has sparked a heated debate over sexism and homophobia in the sport.
Smith’s social media posts during the team’s post-season festivities drew widespread condemnation. Teammate Max Holmes, known for impersonating AFL journalists, dressed as Wilson, continuing a tradition of playful mimicry. However, Smith’s caption, “Caro has never looked better,” accompanied by a suggestive emoji, crossed a line according to many, including Wilson herself.
Controversy and Criticism
Smith’s posts did not stop there. He also shared a photo with captain Patrick Dangerfield, both dressed as cowboys, with a reference to “Brokeback Mountain,” a film known for its portrayal of a same-sex relationship. The caption implied that losing a grand final could turn someone gay, a statement that many found offensive.
Wilson, writing in The Age, did not mince words, labeling Smith a “lawless selfish brat” and accusing him of perpetuating both homophobia and sexism. She highlighted the lack of immediate action from Geelong’s management, questioning the club’s handling of such incidents.
“The club famous for turning lost boys into premiership players has hit a fork in the road with Smith and seems at a genuine loss to know what to do about him,” Wilson wrote.
Comparisons and Consequences
The incident has drawn comparisons to previous controversies within the AFL. Wilson pointed out the disparity in punishment between Smith and GWS players who faced sanctions for their own post-season antics. Toby McMullin and Cooper Hamilton received two-match suspensions for their insensitive costumes, yet Smith remains unscathed.
“Their costumes were in dreadful taste, but compared with Smith? He basically implied that losing a grand final turns you into a gay man – the implication being that’s a bad thing,” Wilson noted.
Former Brownlow Medallist Adam Cooney also weighed in, warning Smith of potential consequences if his behavior continues. Cooney suggested that Smith’s high profile amplifies his actions, making it crucial for him to “pull his head in” to avoid a premature exit from Geelong.
Geelong’s Response and Future Implications
Geelong’s response has been criticized as inadequate. The club issued a generic apology, promising changes to future Mad Monday celebrations but stopped short of directly addressing Smith’s actions. Wilson and others argue that this response misses the point, failing to hold Smith accountable.
Smith, who had a standout season on-field, is no stranger to controversy. Earlier incidents include abusing a photographer and inappropriate gestures towards spectators. These actions, combined with the recent uproar, paint a picture of a player who may be testing the limits of his club’s tolerance.
“Bailey Smith has got to be careful. If he doesn’t pull his head in, in 12 months’ time he’s not going to be at Geelong,” Cooney warned on SEN.
The ongoing debate raises questions about the culture within AFL clubs and the responsibilities of high-profile players. As the league continues to grapple with issues of inclusivity and respect, the handling of incidents like these will likely shape its future direction.
As the dust settles, all eyes will be on Geelong and Smith to see how they navigate the fallout. The club’s next steps could set a precedent for how similar situations are managed in the future, impacting not just the Cats, but the broader AFL community.
