In a season filled with unexpected twists and turns, the AFL’s top players of 2025 have been ranked, revealing significant shifts from pre-season predictions. Notably, two superstars who were once in the top five have seen their standings diminish dramatically. Marcus Bontempelli and Nick Daicos, who began the year with high expectations, now find themselves in unexpected positions within the league’s hierarchy.
On a night marked by surprising selections, Shaun Mannagh, at 28, was awarded the coaches’ best “young player” of 2025, while the All-Australian team captain expressed disbelief at his own selection. The bench for the official team of the year featured the illustrious names of Bontempelli and Daicos, raising eyebrows across the AFL community. Despite missing the first five matches of the season, Bontempelli’s inclusion was a testament to his remarkable talent and determination. However, the decision to place Nick Daicos on the bench was puzzling, especially after he was named the AFLPA MVP for 2025, taking home the prestigious Leigh Matthews Trophy.
The Rise and Fall of AFL’s Elite
The rankings, based on a two-year cycle similar to golf’s Royal and Ancient rankings, reflect not only a player’s performance in a single season but also their consistency and influence over time. While Christian Petracca was initially projected to be a top-three player, alongside Bontempelli and Daicos, his performance in 2025 did not meet expectations. Patrick Cripps, following a second Brownlow win, also faced challenges, resulting in both players dropping out of the top 30.
Meanwhile, Sydney’s Isaac Heeney and Geelong’s Jeremy Cameron have maintained their positions as top performers. Cameron, in particular, has been a standout, with the potential to become the first century goalkicker since Lance Franklin’s peak at Hawthorn 17 years ago.
Emerging Stars and Consistent Performers
The rankings also highlight the emergence of new talent and the consistent excellence of established players. Zak Butters, known for his agility and determination, ranks sixth, while Adelaide’s Jordan Dawson, a likely Brownlow Medal contender, follows closely. Noah Anderson of Gold Coast, a dual threat on the field, holds the seventh position.
Hugh McCluggage, recognized by the All-Australian selectors, has ascended to eighth place, playing a pivotal role in the Brisbane Lions’ success. Harris Andrews and Sam Taylor are acknowledged as the league’s most influential defenders, with Andrews securing a top-ten spot.
Challenges and Opportunities Ahead
The rankings underscore the dynamic nature of the AFL, where one stellar season does not guarantee a top-five or top-ten spot. Players like Max Gawn, Caleb Serong, and Riley Thilthorpe have proven their worth, while others like Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera have the potential to rise significantly in the future.
As the 2025 season concludes, the focus shifts to 2026, where players like Cripps and Petracca will aim to reclaim their status as top-tier athletes. The rankings serve as a reminder of the ever-evolving landscape of the AFL, where performance, consistency, and influence determine a player’s legacy.
Looking Forward: The Next Season
The AFL community eagerly anticipates the 2026 season, with hopes that underperforming stars will bounce back and emerging talents will continue to shine. The rankings not only celebrate the achievements of the past year but also set the stage for the challenges and triumphs that lie ahead.
As the league evolves, so too will the players who define it. The 2025 rankings offer a snapshot of a season filled with surprises, resilience, and the relentless pursuit of excellence.
